Prince Peter Kropotkin was the first thinker since William Godwin to construct a full system of anarcho-collectivism. This collection consists of a bunch of satisfying niblets (yes, niblets) of that system, some better than others.
First, anyone into anarchism has got to read Kropotkins essay of that title for the Encyclopedia Britannica. It has to be the clearest written, most well-stated short intro around. His essay on "The Anarchist Morality (written oddly enough as a retort to some kids who, after stealing some books, justified it with "To each according to his need.")The early essays, which take us through the first hundred-or-so pages are the best, as they get into the underlying theory of anarchism and what "sponteneous order" might look like. Of course "Modern Science and Anarchism" is a complete misnomer because the essay is heavy on philosophical speculation with not much scientific speculation. The latter essays are more-or-less historical propoganda and will be of interest to the history student.
Still, in a world of inarticulate and often unsavory characters, Kropotkin comes off as astute, thoughtful, clear and insightful. Of course, science has (done its best to?)prove Kropotkin wrong on his altruistic evolutionary theories. Even modern "reciprical altruists" in the wake of Dawkins, Wilson and Ridley are looking less altruistic and more reciprical. I guess only time will tell. Hmmmm....
Este é o comentário de um leitor dos livros da Amazon.
Aqui o deixo sem considerações de mérito, ou valor.
Li Kropotkin, quando tinha 16, ou 17 anos de idade em português. Se o tivesse lido em russo melhor seria. Mas infelizmente de russo apenas sei dizer "spassiba" e pouco mais. Li o "príncipe" anarquista pouco antes de ir para a tropa (lembro-me bem!).
Será que o anarquismo e anarco-sindicalismo do "combatente" Emídio Santana, desapareceram com o fim da Guerra Civil de Espanha?
Não tenho a certeza.
Com tanta confusão se calhar vai voltar a ser filosofia institucional daqui por umas décadas.
Vamos vêr como se vai desenrolar a história.
No comments:
Post a Comment